The short answer to Etsy vs Shopify: they do not do the same job. Etsy is a marketplace where buyers are already searching; you pay a small fee per listing and a commission per sale, and most visitors come from Etsy search. Shopify is store infrastructure that runs on your own domain; you pay a monthly subscription, the store and the customer relationship are yours, but you bring the visitors yourself. For a new seller from Turkey with no audience and no ad budget, Etsy is usually the lower-risk first step; for a seller who has an audience or wants to build a brand, Shopify starts to make sense. Below we compare the two on fees, payments, traffic and control.
The core difference: marketplace vs your own store
On Etsy, your shop is a storefront inside Etsy. The buyer searches on Etsy, your listing appears next to other sellers' listings and payment is taken through Etsy's system. Setup is short: an account, a shop name, payment details and a first listing are enough (for the steps, see how to open an Etsy shop).
On Shopify, the store is an independent site. According to Shopify's pricing page, a custom domain can be connected on every plan and every store gets a free myshopify.com address. Theme, pages, payment provider, shipping and legal texts are your responsibility; more freedom means more work.
| Topic | Etsy | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Shop inside a marketplace | Independent store on your own domain |
| Visitors | Come mainly from Etsy search | You bring them (ads, social media, SEO, email) |
| Fixed cost | No mandatory monthly subscription; fee per listing | Monthly subscription |
| Cost per sale | Transaction fee + payment processing fee | Payment provider commission (+ Shopify transaction fee with a third-party provider) |
| Control | Etsy's rules and page layout | Design, domain and customer relationship are yours |
| Setup | Short | Longer; needs technical settings |
How does the fee structure differ?
On Etsy, cost arises together with sales. According to the fees page in Etsy's help center (November 2026):
- A 0.20 USD listing fee per listing; the listing expires after 4 months and another 0.20 USD is charged if it auto-renews.
- A transaction fee of 6.5% of the order total (including shipping and gift wrap) when you make a sale.
- A payment processing fee that varies by country (a set amount plus a percentage).
- A 2.5% currency conversion fee if your listing currency differs from your payment account currency.
- A one-time shop set-up fee when you open the shop, which varies by country.
- If the sale comes from Etsy's Offsite Ads, 15% of the order total (12% for sellers with 10,000 USD or more in sales in the past 365 days), capped at 100 USD per order.
We showed how these items add up on a single product, with an example, in Etsy fees and profit calculation.
On Shopify, the fixed cost comes first. The pricing page lists plans named Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus; all are monthly subscriptions and are paid even if you make no sales. The page also mentions a 3-day free trial. Because plan prices vary by country and billing period, we give no figures here; check the current amount for your own country at shopify.com/pricing.
In short: on Etsy you pay little if you sell little, and the percentage deductions grow as you sell more. On Shopify the subscription is fixed; there is a cost even with no sales, and the share of that fixed cost shrinks as volume grows. Make the decision by calculating with your own product price and expected number of sales, not by guessing.
Getting paid from Turkey: the most critical difference
Shopify Payments, Shopify's own payment solution, does not include Turkey in the list of supported countries in its help center (November 2026). According to Shopify, stores in countries not on the list need to use a third-party payment provider. This has two consequences:
- Before opening the store, you need to find a payment provider that works with your company type in Turkey and learn its commission.
- When a third-party provider is used, Shopify charges a plan-based transaction fee on top of the provider's commission. On the US pricing page this rate is listed as 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus.
On Etsy, payment is collected through Etsy's system and transferred to your account; we explained the process in withdrawing Etsy earnings to Turkey. Whichever platform you choose, a tax obligation arises once you earn regular income: see the guide on taxes and a sole proprietorship for Etsy sales and consult an accountant about your own situation.
Traffic: where do buyers come from?
Etsy's biggest advantage is the ready buyer who searches with an intent to purchase. With the right title, tags and category, even a new shop can appear in search; for this, see how to do Etsy SEO and the Etsy algorithm. If you wish, you can increase visibility with Etsy Ads. The downside is that your listing is always shown on the same page as competitors.
On Shopify, a newly opened store does not get visitors by itself. Ranking on Google takes time, ads take budget, and social media and email take an audience built in advance. In return, the visitor who arrives sees only your products. Shopify's pricing page also lists sales channels on social media and marketplaces on all plans; the store becomes the hub and the other channels connect to it.
Control and risk
On Etsy, Etsy sets the rules: what can be sold, how the listing looks and how communication with the buyer works all depend on the platform's policies. If the account is suspended, sales stop that day; we covered this risk and what to do in my Etsy shop was suspended, what should I do. On Shopify, design, domain and customer relationship are yours; but technical maintenance, payment and shipping setup, the returns process and legal pages are also your job.
What changes for a print on demand seller?
In the print on demand model, the product is printed at the production partner after the order arrives and is shipped to the buyer; this model can be used on both platforms. What matters is which platform your print on demand tool supports (for a comparison, see print on demand sites for Etsy). Printmeet is focused on Etsy: AI design, background removal, mockups, SEO-friendly titles and tags for Etsy, sending the product to Etsy and order/shipping tracking are handled from one panel. Details: Printmeet Etsy integration and how it works.
Which one suits whom?
- Etsy fits better: if you are just starting, have no audience or ad budget, sell gifts, personalized products or print on demand, and want to test an idea with a low fixed cost.
- Shopify fits better: if you have your own audience on social media or an email list, aim for a brand and repeat customers, your product does not fit Etsy's policies, and you can spend time on ads and site management.
- Both together: many sellers validate demand on Etsy first, then add their own store. For another option for your own sales page in Turkey, see using Shopier and Etsy together.
5 questions before you decide
- Do I have an audience that will see my product today, or do I need the platform to bring the buyer?
- Can I afford a monthly subscription in months with no sales?
- Which payment provider works with my company type in Turkey, and what is the total commission?
- How many hours a week can I spend on ads, site maintenance and customer service?
- Does my product comply with Etsy's selling policies?
Transparency note: Printmeet is the platform publishing this article; it works integrated with Etsy and has no integration with Shopify. Etsy fees were taken from the Etsy help center, and Shopify plan and payment information from shopify.com/pricing and the Shopify help center, in November 2026. Fees can change; check the official pages before deciding.
Frequently asked questions
Etsy or Shopify for a beginner?
For someone with no audience and no ad budget, usually Etsy. There is no mandatory monthly subscription, you start at 0.20 USD per listing and buyers can come from Etsy search. Shopify suits sellers who can bring their own visitors.
Is Shopify Payments available in Turkey?
As of November 2026, Turkey is not in the list of supported countries in Shopify's help center. Stores in countries not on the list use a third-party payment provider; in that case Shopify charges an additional plan-based transaction fee.
Is there no commission on Shopify?
There is no per-sale transaction fee like on Etsy, but there is a monthly subscription and the payment provider's commission. If you use a third-party payment provider, Shopify's plan-based transaction fee is added as well.
Can Etsy and Shopify be used at the same time?
Yes. They are separate platforms; you can sell the same products in both places. Keep in mind that you will need to track stock, orders and customer messages from two separate panels.